I’m a DeWalt guy for my carpentry tools, saws mostly. I would say those are both good choices and see what the better deal with battery and charger is. If you can get 2 5hr batteries with a charger, that’s like $200 right there on both companies, so I’d just look for the best package deal offer. Also, regular impact with socket driver and a 5amp DeWalt could not take off over torqued but off my truck.