Is DIY car service worth it for saving on maintenance costs?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #877 Reply
    Shujat

      Is it worth it to do car service on your own? I went to the dealership for basic maintenance oil and filter change—on my 2022 Camry; they quoted $300. We bought this car new and always serviced it at the dealership, but they are increasing the price repeatedly.

      #878 Reply
      Jacob

        Do everything on your own. Start with oil changes and work up from there. You’ll end up saving thousands. Some stuff dealerships charge hundreds for could literally take 3 bolts to DIY (e.g., alternator).

        Before you know it, you’ll spend every minute of your free time cussing out the 2 cars on jackstands in your backyard… you’ll spend every extra dollar you make on rockauto orders… you’ll argue with your wife about keeping cylinder heads on the kitchen counter, washing parts in the bathtub, or changing valve seals in the living room…

        You’ll stumble in at 2 AM after failing yet again to tame a mechanical beast. You’ll have dozens of scratches on your arms, 17 broken tools, and your whole body will be black with oil for days. Your muscles will tremble from exhaustion and plead with you to let them die. The sweet stench of burnt coolant will fill your nostrils as you fall to your knees with only one question – how long? How much longer must I endure this pain before I am called to my eternal place of rest? Why must I suffer so?

        However, the pure power of your new addiction will exert control over you even in that moment, as you mindlessly pull out your phone and scroll marketplace for a third project car you know will never be worth the pain. You’ll finally close your eyes as a single tear rolls down your blood and oil stained cheek.

        Yeah, at that point you’ve gone too far. Ask me how I know. Oil changes are good, though.

        #879 Reply
        Eric

          Do it on your own. You are a man. A man of strength, integrity and honor. Don’t let another man touch your vehicle.

          #880 Reply
          Alacabenzi

            That’s crazy cause the lube tech doing that job will get paid only $6 for it, he’ll have to do more than 15 a day to get 8 hours a day. Strike?

            #881 Reply
            Alex

              Camrys ain’t that hard to service I service em everyday at the dealership if they are charging you 300 then something else is included on that service for a basic oil change where I work at cost around 70$. Depending on the mileage of your Toyota, the service advisors will try and sell you other stuff besides just an oil change like coolant flush or transmission flush and/or additives.

              #882 Reply
              Mike

                It’s clearly not just oil and filter change for $300. There is something else involved in that price.

                #883 Reply
                Adam

                  Toyotas are easy. Buy a pack of oil filters. Go to Walmart and get some Mobil1 synthetic jugs.

                  Find a local guy that others recommend in the marketplace. They’ll usually come out and do it on site for $40-$75 when you have your own oil and filter.

                  I prefer Toyota or mobil1 filters for Toyotas.

                  #884 Reply
                  Atom

                    I have always done my own repairs on my cars, but I grew up with that perspective and someone to teach me how to go about doing it even if I don’t specifically know how to do that job. From fuel pumps, brakes, rotors, drums, to water pumps, to struts, spark plugs, ignition cables, alternators, fly wheels, etc.

                    I almost always do it myself, but I do not change my own oil anymore because of convenience. If they were trying to charge me $300 just for an oil change, I would call them a liar to their face.

                    Even if it’s a full synthetic, it shouldn’t be much more than 1/3 of that if you live in an expensive area and go to an expensive shop.

                    #885 Reply
                    Morgan

                      5 quarts of Costco full synthetic kirkland oil($15) and a good quality filter($10) are $25. Way cheaper to do on your own. Just keep maintenance records and you’ll be fine.

                      #886 Reply
                      Mersch

                        It is worth it if you know what you’re doing. Labor rates are around 245 an hour here, so most of your maintenance is that at a dealer. Independents are less, but not by much. All depends on where you’re at.

                        #887 Reply
                        Amanda

                          There is an oil change door underneath. Filter and drain plug right there. Easy easy. The dealership usually just gives me the drain plug gasket.

                          #888 Reply
                          Raymond

                            You can do it yourself, for $60.
                            Just keep receipts, for future reference.
                            I used to take pictures of oil and filter, if needed for warranty.
                            I change my truck, wife’s Honda civic, and daughter jeep Cherokee.

                            #889 Reply
                            Hannes

                              There is certain things that need to be done at a certain mileage. See if you can find/bribe someone to check Alldata or Autodata, what needs to be done at your current mileage. If it is nothing invasive, all the ‘how to’ on changing the filters will be on YouTube.

                              Personally, I don’t trust dealers. I did a lube change on a Mazda CX5 two weeks ago. Dealers quoted ZAR3200 and I did the job for ZAR1140 and made a profit. As part of a lube service, I usually check/clean the cabin filter. Mazda charged every second service for a cabin filter, and I swear, that filter has never been changed.

                              #890 Reply
                              AL EX

                                Find a reputable garage and go there instead of the dealership. You can ask them to carry out service by the book to maintain your warranty, most of higher quality service garages even stamp your service book as the dealer would as well. Overall it will cost you much less and you won’t have to get dirty.

                                #891 Reply
                                Brian

                                  Depends on how you define “worth it”.

                                  On the surface, it seems cheaper. But you’ll need to invest in tools, albeit not many. You’ll also need to dedicate some time to it. Time ain’t free.

                                  If you’re just talking about oil changes, and you have basic mechanical abilities, it’s not hard at all and there’s not a whole lot of time involved, but disposing of the old oil and filter can be a pain in the butt.

                                  However, there is a lot more to maintenance than just oil changes. Filters, transmission services, brakes, tires, etc. How much you want to do yourself depends. The dealership was probably recommending a complete maintenance service based on mileage rather than a simple oil change.

                                Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
                                Reply To: Is DIY car service worth it for saving on maintenance costs?
                                Your information:




                                Scroll to Top